Niagara Falls
THE
NIAGARA REPORTER
LOCAL NEWS  •  LOCAL VOICES  •  LOCAL MATTERS

Raw sewage discharge into Niagara River unacceptable to Tourism Advisory Board

M
Mike Hudson  ·  October 13, 2017
Raw sewage discharge into Niagara River unacceptable to Tourism Advisory Board
SharefXin

 

Niagara Falls Tourism Advisory Board Chairman Pat Proctor is mad as hell, and he’s not going to take it anymore.

Five times since July, tourists in Niagara Falls have been treated to the spectacle of foul smelling black sludge – untreated sewage – pouring into the river below the Falls. Mr. Proctor said that’s threatening local businesses. Mr. Proctor, who also works as director of marketing at Rainbow Air, the helicopter tour company that gives visitors a bird’s eye view of the mighty Cataracts, made his case public last week.

“With the black water, it’s been a black eye on our area,” he said. “You get a little bit of rain and all of the sudden you’ve got black water and it’s visible to the eye, which isn’t fair to those that have to explain that,” he said. “And there’s a smell that goes with it that God only knows.”

Fifteen years ago, Niagara Falls Mayor Paul Dyster – then a City Council member – spearheaded the drive to divorce water and sewer services from city government. The results have been disastrous.

“If it continues to happen, you’re going to see other businesses in our area suffer from it,” Mr. Proctor said. “They’re going to start wondering the hypothetical question, is the water safe enough to drink? Is it safe to be on the boat? Is it safe to do the Cave of the Winds? Is it safe to be in the area with that smell?”

The Water Board then-Councilman Dyster helped to create says it will cost millions of dollars to make the necessary upgrades to the water treatment system to prevent future problems. But Gov. Andrew Cuomo has openly laughed at the prospect of sending Niagara Falls any more state aid (See related stories).

Unsurprisingly, Mr. Dyster himself has remained largely silent about the fiasco.

“There have been no answers. There’s been no accountability,” Mr. Proctor said. “Why hasn’t anybody stepped up to the plate? Is there anything we can do on our end? We’d be more than willing to help. Letters to the governor, letters to powers that be. Assemblymen, Senators, whoever. We need to fix this problem.”

There were no such problems prior to the creation of the Water Board. But then-Councilman Dyster already had his eye on the mayor’s office and reasoned that Council members not voting on water and sewer rate hikes would protect them – and him, specifically – from the wrath of the taxpayers here.

To a degree he was correct. After all, he’s been elected to the city’s highest office three times in a row.

But with millions of gallons of raw sewage plunging over the falls, the cutoff of millions of dollars in casino cash by the Seneca Nation of Indians and the loss of support by his old buddy, Andrew Cuomo, it looks as though the house of cards he’s built over the past nine years may be tumbling down fast.

SharefXin

Comments (0)

Leave a comment

More From Niagara Falls Reporter

Niagara Falls Hosts Oldest State Park But State Needs to Provide More Assistance
Featured

Niagara Falls Hosts Oldest State Park But State Needs to Provide More Assistance

By tony Farina · August 26, 2026

By Tony Farina The Niagara Falls State Park, located in Niagara Falls, N.Y., and created in 1885, is recognized as the oldest state park in the U.S. and contains the American Falls, the Bridal Veil Falls, and a portion of the Horseshoe Falls (also known as the Canadian Falls). Following a $44-million refurbishment of the 221-acre park in 2003, in 2007 it was named the 10 th most beautiful spot in America by “The Today Show.” According to the state’s Office of Parks, Recreation, and Historic Preservation, the State Park receives more than nine million visits each year. It is

Featured

WEBR to Launch Katie Daye Show on Monday

By tony Farina · August 21, 2026

By Tony Farina There is much excitement in the airwaves at WEBR The Breeze as station manager and program director Frank Miller has announced that beginning on Monday, Aug. 24, the talent he has been hoping to bring in for some time will be joining the WEBR midday lineup from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. every weekday. “We’re just thrilled to be launching the Kadie Daye show on Monday, and we are so looking forward to having a talent like Kadie on our airwaves at WEBR AM 1440, FM 105.3 and FM 106.9,” Miller said in talking about the new

Far Too Often, Promises Have Proved Empty; Niagara Falls Needs Progress And Strategic Planning
Featured

Far Too Often, Promises Have Proved Empty; Niagara Falls Needs Progress And Strategic Planning

By tony Farina · August 4, 2026

By Tony Farina Promises are nice and they bring hope for the future. But unfortunately, most of the time, promises have fallen flat for the City of Niagara Falls, some succeeding but many turning out to be empty promises and major disappointments. At this point, Niagara Falls doesn’t need more failed promises. What the city needs is progress to build a better future and a plan to make it work. City leadership must bring it all together. While there are promises to build a better future on the table and being talked about, like Centennial Park and the Niagara Digital

Governor Issues Response To McMurray’s Letter on Slag Concerns
Featured

Governor Issues Response To McMurray’s Letter on Slag Concerns

By tony Farina · August 4, 2026

By Tony Farina The radioactive slag bubbling up across Niagara County in recent weeks, triggering state and federal testing and some remedial work and family relocations, is the ongoing and seemingly never-ending legacy of the environmental desecration of the past 100-plus years by massive corporations dumping toxic waste that was the subject of Christen Civiletto’s book Thundering Waters. “What we have again is an environmental storm,” said attorney and former Grand Island Supervisor Nate McMurray, a candidate for election to the 45th District State Assembly seat now open because of the retirement of Angelo Morinello. McMurray will run for the