Niagara Falls
THE
NIAGARA REPORTER
LOCAL NEWS  •  LOCAL VOICES  •  LOCAL MATTERS

Garbage tote arson latest chapter In long running comedy sketch

M
Mike Hudson  ·  February 24, 2016
Garbage tote arson latest chapter In long running comedy sketch
SharefXin

 

Niagara Falls – A series of arson fires targeting city-owned garbage totes has become a serious enough concern that both Fire Chief Thomas Colangelo and Police Chief Bryan Dal Porto have asked for the public’s help in identifying the culprits.

In the meantime, Colangelo warned, garbage totes should be kept away from the sides of homes and fences and instead placed in the rear or middle of yards. He also advised that totes not be left unattended outside of garbage pick-up times.

This past weekend, two fires spread from burning totes to ignite nearby residences. A fire in the 2400 block of Whitney Avenue Sunday spread inside a home and set it aflame, climbing an outside wall and through a broken window. Five people escaped with their lives.

Niagara Falls Mayor Paul Dyster’s “recycling plan” has been troubled from the start. Startup costs of $2.3 million to buy and deliver some 10,000 new blue (64 gallon) refuse totes and (96 gallon) recycling green totes, along with $78,000 a year for city employees to oversee the program came at a time when the recycling industry is slumping badly.

Although Dyster claimed the program would save the city $500,000 annually, it quickly became apparent that the city would lose money. Small businesses faced increased costs and residents faced fines and other sanctions for not complying. Outraged taxpayers, led by Third Street businessman and longtime Dyster supporter Craig Avery, called publicly for the resignation of City Administrator Donna Owens, who Dyster credited for creating the plan.

In 2013, the last full year prior to Dyster’s recycling plan, the city paid Modern Disposal Inc. of Lewiston about $2.9 million for trash collection. In 2015, the first full year city residents will get to enjoy the fruits of Dyster’s tote plan, taxpayers were socked with a whopping tab of nearly $3.8 million.

Fire Chief Thomas Colangelo told the Niagara Falls City Council Monday his department has responded to a number of blazes in alleyways and near homes. The “heaviest concentration” has been reported in the Falls’ mid-city and downtown areas – Whitney to Forest avenues between 18th and 24th streets – during the late evening hours, 7 p.m. to 1 a.m.

“The majority of them have been started in city-owned garbage totes,” he said.

Colangelo noted that arson, even to a garbage tote, is a felony crime in the state of New York.

“I don’t think whoever is starting these fires are aware of that,” Colangelo said. “The fire and police departments are taking these fires very seriously and will not stop investigating until we find the person or persons responsible.”

Police Superintendent Bryan DalPorto said that, although it may appear like a series of small crimes, the property damage to totes and structures will add up and his department intends to “fully investigate” the matter.

On the various Facebook pages dedicated to Niagara Falls news, this latest chapter in Dyster’s trash plan folly was treated like a new episode in some bizarre television sitcom.

“How else do you expect all the homeless in the city to keep warm geez?” asked Matthew Newman.

Alan Chortie paraphrased the bumbling Sgt. Schultz on the old “Hogan’s Heroes” comedy program. “With all the security cameras, and cell phones no one knows anything?” he asked.

Gregg Larkin brought up an earlier pratfall. James Dolson, the man Dyster picked to play “Totes McGoats,” described as the city’s recycling mascot and children’s liason, was convicted of dealing heroin.

“Totes McGoats was replaced with a cardboard cutout,” Larkin wrote. “This is his way of getting even. Stick it to the man, Totes!”

Jeffrey S. Bykowicz joined in the fun.

“Has Totes McGoats been questioned?” Bykowicz asked.

One possibility overlooked by city officials and Facebook wags alike is that, perhaps, the garbage tote fires are a form of protest against a massive fail by the Dyster administration, similar to the rash parking meter pole cuttings that occurred when then-mayor Irene Elia attempted to push through an unpopular parking plan.

totie v
The Mayor and his mascot for the controversial trash removal and recycling program. Paul Dyster [l] and Totes McGoats [r].
Stick it to the man indeed.

SharefXin

Comments (0)

Leave a comment

More From Niagara Falls Reporter

Niagara Falls Hosts Oldest State Park But State Needs to Provide More Assistance
Featured

Niagara Falls Hosts Oldest State Park But State Needs to Provide More Assistance

By tony Farina · August 26, 2026

By Tony Farina The Niagara Falls State Park, located in Niagara Falls, N.Y., and created in 1885, is recognized as the oldest state park in the U.S. and contains the American Falls, the Bridal Veil Falls, and a portion of the Horseshoe Falls (also known as the Canadian Falls). Following a $44-million refurbishment of the 221-acre park in 2003, in 2007 it was named the 10 th most beautiful spot in America by “The Today Show.” According to the state’s Office of Parks, Recreation, and Historic Preservation, the State Park receives more than nine million visits each year. It is

Featured

WEBR to Launch Katie Daye Show on Monday

By tony Farina · August 21, 2026

By Tony Farina There is much excitement in the airwaves at WEBR The Breeze as station manager and program director Frank Miller has announced that beginning on Monday, Aug. 24, the talent he has been hoping to bring in for some time will be joining the WEBR midday lineup from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. every weekday. “We’re just thrilled to be launching the Kadie Daye show on Monday, and we are so looking forward to having a talent like Kadie on our airwaves at WEBR AM 1440, FM 105.3 and FM 106.9,” Miller said in talking about the new

Far Too Often, Promises Have Proved Empty; Niagara Falls Needs Progress And Strategic Planning
Featured

Far Too Often, Promises Have Proved Empty; Niagara Falls Needs Progress And Strategic Planning

By tony Farina · August 4, 2026

By Tony Farina Promises are nice and they bring hope for the future. But unfortunately, most of the time, promises have fallen flat for the City of Niagara Falls, some succeeding but many turning out to be empty promises and major disappointments. At this point, Niagara Falls doesn’t need more failed promises. What the city needs is progress to build a better future and a plan to make it work. City leadership must bring it all together. While there are promises to build a better future on the table and being talked about, like Centennial Park and the Niagara Digital

Governor Issues Response To McMurray’s Letter on Slag Concerns
Featured

Governor Issues Response To McMurray’s Letter on Slag Concerns

By tony Farina · August 4, 2026

By Tony Farina The radioactive slag bubbling up across Niagara County in recent weeks, triggering state and federal testing and some remedial work and family relocations, is the ongoing and seemingly never-ending legacy of the environmental desecration of the past 100-plus years by massive corporations dumping toxic waste that was the subject of Christen Civiletto’s book Thundering Waters. “What we have again is an environmental storm,” said attorney and former Grand Island Supervisor Nate McMurray, a candidate for election to the 45th District State Assembly seat now open because of the retirement of Angelo Morinello. McMurray will run for the